Category Archives: Cold Cases

Roger Pleaugh-45 Year Old White Male

Victim was found by 448 W. Georgia St. on 11/13/05 and was transported to the hospital due to having head injuries.  He told officers he had been beaten up and some items taken from him at his makeshift camp.  He died from injuries on 11/21/05.

Tony Pierrelouis-24 Year Old Black Male

On 4/16/05, the victim was struck and killed by gunfire in his vehicle outside of the Calypso Cafe in the 1600 Block of Mills St. There were several people outside of the club at the time of the incident, but when officers arrived most had left the scene.

Leslie Ann Oswalt-27 Year Old White Female

Victim was found in an alley between 7th and 8th St. in Apalachicola, FL on 10/26/03, there was blunt trauma to the head.  Oswalt was known to have been partying within two blocks of where she was found.

Ruth Thompson-82 Year Old Female

Thompson was found murdered inside of her residence, located at 921 Paul Russell Rd. in Tallahassee, FL on 04/21/1985.  The victim lived alone at the time of death, but she did take on boarders on occasion.  The investigation revealed the victim died as a result of foul play.

Johnnie Kornegay-36 Year Old White Male

Kornegay of Tallahassee, a taxicab driver, was killed during what is believed to be a robbery.  He was found inhis yelow cab near the intersection of Brevard and Woodward St. on 12/19/64.  Kornegay picked up a passenger at the taxi stand next to the Greyhound Bus Station on Adams St. prior to being found murdered.

Pamela S. Kinney-19 Year Old Black Female

Victim’s remains were found in a wooded area off of Tilton Rd. west of Apalachicola, FL on 09/05/05.  She was reported missing by family and friends on 08/15/05.  Investigation reveals that Pamela was killed in a rental house on St. George Island, FL.

Earl D. Ervin-55 Year Old White Male

On Saturday, 08/15/87, the victim`s body was found beaten to death inside of the Solid Waste Division facility located at 2727 Municipal Way at approx. 8:00pm.  Ervin was returining some property when he may have interrupted a burglary.  There was a black female who called 911 several days after the incident occured who wished to…

Isaac Dupree III-Black Male

On 04/02/02, the victim was murdered while inside of his residence located at 3710 Aksarben Dr., Tallahassee, FL.  Witnesses reported seeing several people flee from the area.

Sylvester Davis Jr.-33 Year Old Black Male

The victim was found murdered in his residence located at 1521 Arnold St. Tallahassee, FL on 10/26/05.  Investigation revealed that Davis died as a result of foul play.

Martha “Cal” Battles

On Sunday, 10/08/06 the victim was found deceased, and is believed to have been murdered sometime between Saturday 10/07/06 and early Sunday morning 10/08/06.  The victim may have been in the area of Frenchtown in Tallahassee, FL on Saturday 10/07/06 driving a vehicle similar to the one shown above.

Call Local

(850) 574-TIPS (8477)

Text a Tip

Text "BBCS" plus your tip to 274637


1-888-876-TIPS (8477)

Send Online - Submit a Tip

Capital City Bank logo
LCSO logo
Cumulus logo
Fox49 logo
TheCW logo
Tallahassee Fire Dept logo
City of Tallahassee logo
TPD logo
NBC 40 logo
abc27 logo